CAN-SPAM for dunning and win-back emails
Failed-payment emails and win-back emails look alike but are treated differently. Here's what the FTC says, and how our templates handle it.
What the FTC says
- CAN-SPAM covers commercial email, meaning messages whose primary purpose is to advertise or promote a product or service, and it has no exception for business-to-business email. Source: CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business (Federal Trade Commission (dated August 2023, edited January 2024))
- A message whose content is only transactional or relationship content (for example, it completes or confirms a transaction the person already agreed to, or tells them about a change in their standing in an ongoing subscription or membership) must not have false or misleading routing information, but is otherwise exempt from most of the Act. Source: CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business (Federal Trade Commission (dated August 2023, edited January 2024))
- The FTC says these categories are read narrowly: a message isn't transactional just because it goes to a subscriber or member. Source: CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business (Federal Trade Commission (dated August 2023, edited January 2024))
- If an email mixes both kinds of content, it is treated as commercial when the subject line would lead a reasonable reader to think it's an ad, or when the transactional part doesn't come mainly at the beginning. Source: CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business (Federal Trade Commission (dated August 2023, edited January 2024))
- Commercial email must use accurate header information and a subject line that matches the content, identify itself as an ad, include a valid physical postal address, and explain clearly how to opt out of future marketing email. Source: CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business (Federal Trade Commission (dated August 2023, edited January 2024))
- Opt-out requests must be honored within 10 business days, and the opt-out method must keep working for at least 30 days after you send the message. Source: CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business (Federal Trade Commission (dated August 2023, edited January 2024))
- Subscribers and members can opt out of marketing email even though they have a subscription with you. Source: CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business (Federal Trade Commission (dated August 2023, edited January 2024))
- The FTC's guide lists penalties of up to $53,088 for each email that violates the Act (the figure as edited in January 2024). Source: CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business (Federal Trade Commission (dated August 2023, edited January 2024))
- Other countries have their own rules. Canada, for example, has its own anti-spam legislation (CASL). Source: Canada's anti-spam legislation (Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada)
How our templates handle it
- The four payment emails and the cancellation confirmation stick to the account and the payment, with the transactional content first and no promotions.
- Every template has a
{{physical_address}}placeholder in the footer and an accurate subject line. - The optional win-back email is labeled as a promotional email from your business, includes your postal address and an
{{unsubscribe_link}}, and uses a subject line that says what it is. - Send from a real address that accepts replies, with accurate From and Reply-To details.
Checklist before you send
- Subject line matches the content.
- From and Reply-To are accurate.
- Payment information comes first; no promotions in the payment emails.
- Your real postal address is in the footer.
- Marketing emails have a working unsubscribe link, honored within 10 business days.
- Checked the rules for customers outside the US.
- A lawyer has reviewed your final emails.
Questions
Do failed-payment emails need an unsubscribe link?
A message that only deals with an existing subscription's payment is generally transactional or relationship content, which the FTC says is exempt from most of CAN-SPAM. Adding promotions can change that. A win-back email to a former customer is marketing and needs an opt-out.
Do I need my postal address in a transactional email?
CAN-SPAM's postal address rule is for commercial email. We include an address placeholder in every template anyway, because it costs nothing and keeps you covered if an email drifts into promotion.
Does this cover customers outside the US?
No. Other countries have their own rules, such as Canada's CASL. Check the law where your customers are.
Facts checked against the linked official sources on November 20, 2026. Laws and Stripe's products change; follow the links for the current version.
Not legal advice. General information, not legal advice. Email and cancellation rules depend on where you and your customers are and on what each message says. Have a lawyer review your own emails and cancel flow, and check the official sources we link.