The 4-email sequence that wins back failed cards
A failed card is often an accident: an expired card, a replaced card, a bank being careful. The job of a dunning sequence is to make the fix obvious and fast, then stop.
| When (14-day window) | What it says | Type | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Day 0 | The payment failed. Here's the link to fix it. | Transactional |
| 2 | Day 4 | Still failing. Here are the usual fixes. | Transactional |
| 3 | Day 8 | What changes, and on what date, if it isn't fixed. | Transactional |
| 4 | Day 14 | Final notice on the last retry. Then stop. | Transactional |
| + | 2–4 weeks later | Optional win-back with an unsubscribe link. | Marketing |
What each email does
- Day 0: the facts and the link. Say what failed, for how much, and where to fix it. No threats. The plan is still active.
- A few days later: the usual fixes. New card, a bank block, or another way to pay. Add a line that fits your business.
- Past halfway: the consequence and the date. What stops, and when. List only what's really true for your business.
- Last retry: final notice. One last link and a graceful way out. Then stop emailing about this payment.
The win-back email is optional and different: it's marketing, so CAN-SPAM's requirements apply. See CAN-SPAM for dunning emails.
Line the emails up with your retries
- Stripe's Smart Retries retries failed subscription and invoice payments. Stripe says it is on by default for new accounts and set to up to 8 retries within 2 weeks; you can choose a window of 1 week, 2 weeks, 3 weeks, 1 month or 2 months. Source: Automate payment retries (Stripe documentation)
- Stripe doesn't retry some failures, including hard declines such as lost_card, stolen_card, incorrect_number and authentication_required, until the customer adds a new payment method. Source: Automate payment retries (Stripe documentation)
- When retries run out, Stripe can cancel the subscription, mark it unpaid, leave it past due, or pause it if the subscription is eligible, depending on your settings. Source: Automate payment retries (Stripe documentation)
- Stripe can email your customer after each failed card payment, with a link to update the payment method, if you turn on “Send emails when card payments fail”. It can also email customers before a card on file expires. Source: Automate customer emails (Stripe documentation)
- Stripe lists automatic card updates among its revenue recovery features: it updates a customer's card details when they get a new card number. Source: Revenue recovery (Stripe documentation)
Our generator lets you pick a 7, 14, 21 or 28-day window and spaces the emails across it.
Why did the card fail? The decline code changes what email 2 should say. Look it up on Decline Decoder, our free sister site (also run by Diamond Ray Inc): expired_card, insufficient_funds, do_not_honor, generic_decline, authentication_required. It also has a failed-payment calculator.
Questions
How many dunning emails should I send?
We suggest four across your retry window, then stop, plus an optional win-back later. Keep each one short. If your own results show a different number works better for your customers, use that.
Should every email include the update link?
Yes. One clear link in every email, as early as possible.
What if the decline is a hard decline?
Stripe won't retry hard declines such as a lost or stolen card until the customer adds a new payment method, so the emails are the only way back. Say plainly that a new card is needed.
Facts checked against the linked official sources on November 20, 2026. Laws and Stripe's products change; follow the links for the current version.
Not legal advice. General information, not legal advice. Email and cancellation rules depend on where you and your customers are and on what each message says. Have a lawyer review your own emails and cancel flow, and check the official sources we link.